The Evolution of the Species: Successfully Managing Franchise System Change
Home // Business // Franchise
File Size: 91.59 KB
Category: Business & Franchise
Source: www.wiggin.com
Nevertheless, successful franchisors have no choice but to As these decisions reflect,
franchise and development
Share this info:
Content Inside:
The Evolution of the Species: Successfully Managing Franchise System Change EDWARD WOOD DUNHAM AND KIMBERLY S. TOOMEY It is not the strongest of the species that survive, nor the most intel- survey cases addressing a variety of system change issues ligent, but the one most responsive to change.—Charles Darwin and offer recommendations to help franchisors gain fran- Darwin’s theory of natural selection posits that as chisee support, avoid claims, and protect themselves if environmental conditions change, species adapt by litigation ensues. the survival and proliferation of those that have the A Few Basic Principles most favorable characteristics for the given conditions. Despite the risks in implementing system change, franchisors Through the slow process of inherited characteristics and should take some comfort in the legal system, which general- natural selection, species evolve over generations.1 ly supports a franchisor’s right to modify its system in In modern business, of course, change happens much response to market forces. For all the changes in logos, more rapidly. The natural selection process, operating at menus, marketing strategies, and unit designs and sizes that warp speed, can blow previously successful enterprises off have occurred in countless franchise systems over the years, the road if they neglect to evolve, and franchise systems are there are few reported cases directly addressing challenges to no exception. To prosper long-term, franchisors must adapt systemwide changes, and most of these have upheld the fran- to changing demographics, consumer preferences, competi- chisor’s right to adapt and improve its system. tors, and technology by modifying their business concepts, A review of this precedent yields two generally disposi- operating procedures, products, and services. Moreover, tive principles. First, a franchisor cannot breach a franchise successful adaptation can never be the product of franchisor agreement by acting according to its express terms. When fiat; it requires the active cooperation of franchisees, which franchisees have claimed that system changes breached can often be difficult to obtain. their franchise agreements, franchisors have generally pre- Consumers frequently want something new and differ- vailed by relying on the express franchise agreement reser- ent, but franchisees entering long-term franchise agree- vation of rights, allowing a franchisor to change the system ments may assume that the concept and products will in its sole discretion and as may be required from time to remain substantially the same for the life of the contract. time. The franchise agreement language reserving the fran- This servicing of two constituencies, i.e., consumers and chisor’s right to modify the concept is often the deciding franchisees, often places franchisors in the difficult position of seeking to improve the system by implementing changes factor in resolving breach of contract claims through sum- that consumers desire but franchisees resist. mary judgment. A warning, however: Whatever the con- For franchisors, therefore, survival requires not only the tract may say, absolute discretion rarely exists in the real ability to adapt to changing environments, but also the skill world. Accordingly, if they want to defeat system change of justifying to franchisees change and its accompanying claims, franchisors exercising discretion under their fran- costs and disruption. When system changes either do not chise agreements should act with commercially reasonable, improve or, in the worst case, substantially harm a fran- not arbitrary or capricious, business judgment. chisee’s financial position, the franchisor may face not only Second, the law does not require a franchisor to guaran- resistance, but also a variety of claims, including charges tee the success of its strategy. Mistakes and misjudgments that it (1) fundamentally altered the original system, there- are part of business, and a failed strategy alone does not by breaching the franchise agreement or the implied prove franchisor liability. If a franchisor can demonstrate covenant of good faith and fair dealing, or (2) violated the that it had a reasonable basis for changing its system and franchisee’s statutory protections. reasonably believed that the changes would benefit the sys- Nevertheless, successful franchisors have no choice but tem, most courts are unwilling to second-guess that busi- to continually adapt their systems to evolving circum- ness judgment, whatever its consequences might have been stances. In a marketplace that can shift quickly from low-fat for a particular franchisee.2 to low-carbohydrate diets and from the importance of per- Franchisee protection statutes, however, may create an sonal attention to the ease of e-commerce, no business can exception to this rule. In New Jersey, for instance, the cling too tightly to tradition without sacrificing market franchise relationship statute provides powerful support for share and eventually jeopardizing its existence. Careful a franchisee’s claims that system change has violated its planning and thoughtful implementation increase the bene- rights.3 Under the statute, discussed in more detail below, fits and decrease the risks of adaptation. This article will franchisors cannot require franchisees to execute renewal contracts with substantially different terms, and franchisors are prohibited from requiring an “unreasonable standard of Edward Wood Dunham is a partner in the New Haven, Connecticut, office of Wiggin & Dana; Kimberly S. Toomey is an associate in the performance.”4 When dealing with any franchisee protected firm’s Philadelphia office. by a franchise relationship statute, franchisors should be Number 4 • Volume 24 • Spring 2005 • American Bar Association • Franchise Law Journal • 231 “The Evolution of the Species: Successfully Managing Franchise System Change” by Edward Wood Dunham and Kimberly S. Toomey, published in Franchise Law Journal, Volume 24, No.4, Spring 2005 © 2005 by the American Bar Association. Reproduced by permission. All rights reserved. This information or any por- tion thereof may not be copied or disseminated in any form or by any means or stored in an electronic database or retrieval system without the express written consent of the American Bar Association.
Comments
Related PDF Files
Today Terms
daftar harga suku cadang motor yamaha, harga mobil pickup bekas, harga motor yamaha 135lc, noken as, process control by marlin solution manual, izuzu-phanter, dzogchen center surya das, salicylate free avon, www. yamha jupiterz.com, harga striping supra x 125 R, www.mesin honda modif.com, free e-books, sherlock holmes script pdf, supra X 125 injection, nikon 700d vs canon 5d, harga tie rod toyota corolla, hubberts peak rapidshare, human anatomy and physiology 8th edition download, www.yamaha jupiter z.com, mobil10jt-an, hargamotorbekashondasupra125injection, isuzu panther bekas, Beginning ASP.NET E-Commerce in C: From Novice to Professional fyletype:pdf, The Solid Earth %E2 An Introduction to Global Geophysics torrent, rcvandegraaf, dvr4c on internet, dvr4c on internet, doelstelling anatomische les, introduction to statistical quality control pdf, toko onderdil isuzupather surabaya, HARGA isuzu panther 2009, biology of microorganisms madigan, download, free pdf ebooks, autoradio citroen xsara, JOSE DE JESUS RUBIO AVILA, onderdil racing motor, Buch eos 5d mark II .pdf rapidshare, The Dzogchen Center, rapidshare Bosch Handbook for Automotive Electrics - Automotive Electronics 5th Edition, microbiology an evolving science ifile.it, desenvolvendo websites com php, daftar harga suku cadang toyota, microbiology an evolving science pdf download ifile, Vim 101 Hacks download, microbiology an evolving science pdf download, download Livro Desenvolvendo Websites com PHP, panther 2004, data yamaha jupiter 2009, autoradio xsara, pdf source, matlab simulation of synchronous generator, Harga Isuzu Panther Touring Bekas, sap pdf files, motor suzuki genuine part, pdf e-books strategic planning 2009, Fundamentals of Anatomy and Physiology 6th Edition PDF, supra honda 2000*spesifikasi, daftar harga isuzu panther bekas, harga isuzu panther touring, harga mobil bekas fanther grand taoring 2005, Renault DPO, hand book of print media, the machine that changed the world pdf, Spesifikasi Honda supra fit S, linear optimal control systems kwakernaak rapidshare, about honda supra x 125 cw, spesifikasi honda supra x 125, torrent lasts anatomy, Harga second jupiter z 2010, izusu panther, suku supra x, www.yamaha.com.my, meditations on the occult life pdf, pdf source, accesories isuzu panther, harga onderdil motor, download process control thomas marlin book, deap version 2.1, isuzu panther bekas pick up, onderdil jupiter z, suzuki satria lscm, hargayamaham12009, James Womack Daniel Jones and Daniel Roos called The Machine That Changed the World, suku cadang mazda 626, spesifikasi motor honda new supra x 125 cw, tamiya artikelnummer 58248, suku cadang mazda, introduction to statistical quality control for biology, izuzu panter 2005, daftar harga onderdil mazda, biology of microorganisms ebook, harga onderdil isuzu panther, honda 125 injection, download confessions of an advertising man, PDF SOURCE, harga yamaha jupiter 2009, daftar harga truk isuzu elf bekas, Harga Jupiter 2005, daftarhargasukucadangmobil, spesifikasi mesin supra x 125, Desenvolvendo Websites com PHP download, Rosen TY0710 new york, harga truk, daftar harga truk isuzu elf, m0bil panther, onderdil yamaha, harga panther pick up 90-an, harga panther pick up 90-an, more...