On the role of familiarity with units of measurement in categorical accentuation: Tajfel and Wilkes …
Home // Electrical and Electronics // Units of Measurement
File Size: 55.43 KB
Category: Electrical and Electronics & Units of Measurement
Source: www.psor.ucl.ac.be, Author: Comp4
Page: 4 pages
VOL. 13, NO. 4, JULY 2002 ON THE ROLE OF FAMILIARITY WITH UNITS OF MEASUREMENT IN
CATEGORICAL ACCENTUATION: Tajfel and Wilkes (1963) Revisited and Replicated
Share this info:
Content Inside:
PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE
Research Report
ON THE ROLE OF FAMILIARITY WITH UNITS OF MEASUREMENT IN CATEGORICAL ACCENTUATION: Tajfel and Wilkes (1963) Revisited and Replicated Olivier Corneille,1 Olivier Klein,2 Sophie Lambert,2 and Charles M. Judd3
1
Catholic University of Louvain, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium; 2Free University of Brussels, Brussels, Belgium; and 3University of Colorado at Boulder
Abstract—The present article provides evidence for the role of participants’ familiarity with units of measurement in categorical accentuation with unidimensional physical estimates. Belgian and American participants estimated the lengths of lines varying in length. Depending on the condition, the lines were or were not systematically associated with categorical labels, and the estimates were made either in inches or in centimeters. Consistent with our predictions, (a) categorical accentuation was higher when the lines were systematically categorized than when they were not, and (b) this effect was stronger when participants reported their estimates in an unfamiliar measurement unit (i.e., Belgian participants using inches, and American participants using centimeters). These findings support the view that people’s reliance on categorical information is more likely to emerge given uncertain contexts of judgment. Additionally, they may help explain why researchers have had difficulties replicating the categorical accentuation effect in the past. Almost 40 years ago, Tajfel and Wilkes (1963) reported their nowclassic experiment in which they asked participants to estimate category exemplars (i.e., lines) that varied continuously along a physical dimension (i.e., length). Participants provided their estimates in one of three conditions: Longer lines were systematically given a different label from shorter lines, each line was randomly given one of the two labels, or no labels were presented. Tajfel and Wilkes sought to demonstrate the cognitive-perceptual origin of stereotypes, that is, the exaggeration of perceived differences (resemblances) between members of different (the same) social groups. Specifically, the authors predicted that the systematic association of categorical labels with exemplars that varied along a physical continuum would (a) increase the perceived differences between exemplars from different categories and (b) decrease the perceived differences among exemplars of the same category. The results were consistent with the first prediction: Participants perceived a greater difference between the shortest of the long lines and the longest of the short lines in the systematic-categorization condition than in the other two conditions. Thus, participants’ estimates of the exemplars that straddled the category boundaries were more differentiated in that condition than in the others. Despite its apparent simplicity, this study played a key role both in the study of the cognitive processes involved in stereotyping and in the elaboration of social identity theory (see, e.g., Hogg & Abrams, 1988;
Address correspondence to Olivier Corneille, Catholic University of Louvain, Department of Experimental Psychology (UPSO), Place du Cardinal Mercier, 10, B-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium; e-mail: olivier.corneille@ psp.ucl.ac.be.
Tajfel, 1969, 1978). This categorical accentuation effect, somewhat akin to the categorical perception effect evidenced in a more recent literature (e.g., Harnad, 1987), gave rise to an abundant body of research in cognitive social psychology. Similar effects were observed in the context of estimates about attitude statements (Eiser, 1971; Eiser & Stroebe, 1972; Eiser & Van der Pligt, 1984; McGarty & Penny, 1988), trait valences (Krueger & Rothbart, 1990), daily temperatures (Krueger & Clement, 1994), body weights (Krueger, Rothbart, & Sriram, 1989), and colors (Goldstone, 1995). They were also shown to emerge in judgments of category exemplars that varied along multiple dimensions (Corneille & Judd, 1999; Ford & Stangor, 1992; Goldstone, 1994, 1996; Livingston, Andrews, & Harnad, 1998). Curiously, however, researchers had a hard time reproducing the classic effect when using the original paradigm, which, as discussed, involved estimates of line lengths (see, e.g., Andrews & Livingston, 2000; Lambert, 1999; McGarty, 1999). In his recent book on categorization in social psychology, McGarty (1999) noted that he had “lost count of the number of researchers who have told [him] that they attempted without success to replicate Tajfel and Wilkes’ results using the original labeled line-judgment paradigm or minor variations on it” (McGarty, 1999, p. 73). Even more recently, Andrews and Livingston (2000) repeatedly failed to replicate the original effect and suggested that Tajfel and Wilkes’s findings were probably due to demand characteristics of the task situation. These authors also noted that the effect could be obtained, but “only with multidimensional stimuli and only when the categories require learning (as opposed to the simple attachment of labels to known categories, as in Tajfel and Wilkes)” (Andrews & Livingston, 2000, p. 1015). In agreement with Andrews and Livingston (2000), we believe that multidimensionality and learning are likely to enhance categorical accentuation. The issue, however, is whether these conditions are necessary for the effect to emerge, or, alternatively, if categorical accentuation can be obtained in conditions more akin to Tajfel and Wilkes’s original paradigm. We hypothesized that categorical accentuation has the potential to emerge in unidimensional physical estimates (and given the simple pairing of categorical labels to stimuli), but that it will more likely do so given relatively high levels of uncertainty in the judgment task. In making this prediction, we relied on Tajfel and Wilkes’s theoretical framework, in which the authors noted that “the class identification of a stimulus provides a supplementary source of information about the relationship of its magnitude with the magnitude of other stimuli” (Tajfel & Wilkes, 1963, p. 103). We assumed that participants would be more likely to rely on such a secondary source of information when experiencing uncertainty in the judgment task. Indeed, categorical labels may help them overcome their uncertainty regarding estimates. This argument is compatible with several studies showing that in conditions of subjective uncertainty, people preferably use categorical information to define themselves and others
VOL. 13, NO. 4, JULY 2002
380
Copyright © 2002 American Psychological Society
Comments
Related PDF Files
Today Terms
daftar harga suku cadang motor yamaha, harga mobil pickup bekas, harga motor yamaha 135lc, noken as, process control by marlin solution manual, izuzu-phanter, dzogchen center surya das, salicylate free avon, www. yamha jupiterz.com, harga striping supra x 125 R, www.mesin honda modif.com, free e-books, sherlock holmes script pdf, supra X 125 injection, nikon 700d vs canon 5d, harga tie rod toyota corolla, hubberts peak rapidshare, human anatomy and physiology 8th edition download, www.yamaha jupiter z.com, mobil10jt-an, hargamotorbekashondasupra125injection, isuzu panther bekas, Beginning ASP.NET E-Commerce in C: From Novice to Professional fyletype:pdf, The Solid Earth %E2 An Introduction to Global Geophysics torrent, rcvandegraaf, dvr4c on internet, dvr4c on internet, doelstelling anatomische les, introduction to statistical quality control pdf, toko onderdil isuzupather surabaya, HARGA isuzu panther 2009, biology of microorganisms madigan, download, free pdf ebooks, autoradio citroen xsara, JOSE DE JESUS RUBIO AVILA, onderdil racing motor, Buch eos 5d mark II .pdf rapidshare, The Dzogchen Center, rapidshare Bosch Handbook for Automotive Electrics - Automotive Electronics 5th Edition, microbiology an evolving science ifile.it, desenvolvendo websites com php, daftar harga suku cadang toyota, microbiology an evolving science pdf download ifile, Vim 101 Hacks download, microbiology an evolving science pdf download, download Livro Desenvolvendo Websites com PHP, panther 2004, data yamaha jupiter 2009, autoradio xsara, pdf source, matlab simulation of synchronous generator, Harga Isuzu Panther Touring Bekas, sap pdf files, motor suzuki genuine part, pdf e-books strategic planning 2009, Fundamentals of Anatomy and Physiology 6th Edition PDF, supra honda 2000*spesifikasi, daftar harga isuzu panther bekas, harga isuzu panther touring, harga mobil bekas fanther grand taoring 2005, Renault DPO, hand book of print media, the machine that changed the world pdf, Spesifikasi Honda supra fit S, linear optimal control systems kwakernaak rapidshare, about honda supra x 125 cw, spesifikasi honda supra x 125, torrent lasts anatomy, Harga second jupiter z 2010, izusu panther, suku supra x, www.yamaha.com.my, meditations on the occult life pdf, pdf source, accesories isuzu panther, harga onderdil motor, download process control thomas marlin book, deap version 2.1, isuzu panther bekas pick up, onderdil jupiter z, suzuki satria lscm, hargayamaham12009, James Womack Daniel Jones and Daniel Roos called The Machine That Changed the World, suku cadang mazda 626, spesifikasi motor honda new supra x 125 cw, tamiya artikelnummer 58248, suku cadang mazda, introduction to statistical quality control for biology, izuzu panter 2005, daftar harga onderdil mazda, biology of microorganisms ebook, harga onderdil isuzu panther, honda 125 injection, download confessions of an advertising man, PDF SOURCE, harga yamaha jupiter 2009, daftar harga truk isuzu elf bekas, Harga Jupiter 2005, daftarhargasukucadangmobil, spesifikasi mesin supra x 125, Desenvolvendo Websites com PHP download, Rosen TY0710 new york, harga truk, daftar harga truk isuzu elf, m0bil panther, onderdil yamaha, harga panther pick up 90-an, harga panther pick up 90-an, more...